Showing posts with label commitment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label commitment. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Commitment for Life - Part 2; The Western Marraige

Marriage is the triumph of imagination over intelligence............Oscar Wilde.

Talking about westerners has always amused me. Here we talk about their marriage ceremony and ours. Lets see, lets talk about the United States. Indians go out on a limb these days to mimic the people out there. 

A guy sees a girl in a restaurant, bar, pub, workplace or any public place. He goes up to her - if he has guts - and uses any of the "pickup lines". Like, can I buy you a drink or something similar. They talk and see if they have anything in common, if they both feel the same way, they end up on a date. Now a date is completely different from what we guys perceive it as(This statement is based on a story that I heard in my office, where I suggested to a guy that he should ask a girl he likes on a date and he responded - dude, its too soon). It is a commitment, to go out with somebody, and have a dinner or have a drink or a game or even a concert. Anything that two people would do. Again the objective of the date is mostly to get to know each other more than anything else - if you know what I mean. Anyway jokes apart, a number of dates and probably spending a few nights together they come to a conclusion that they are in fact in love. Now as per a normal westerner, being in love does not mean they are committed, that is the next step. Usually the guy goes up with a ring to the girl, kneels down on one knee and asks "will you marry me". If he is lucky enough she will say yes. Then they are committed and slowly get married. 

The western marriage is quite a thing as it is here. There is a usual feeling that the bride tend to freak out as the marriage gets closer and rightly so. If you look at it, a western wedding, its all about the bride.  The bride the special person in a wedding. The groom usually picks up a best man, who is a friend, and as the name suggests, usually is a male. The best man holds the ring, which the groom puts on the bride's hand during the wedding. On the other hand, the bride picks up a bride's maid, who is a friend and as the name suggests, is usually a female. 

Now from the experience that I have had with American people, the wedding is usually decided by the bride and the groom. They are very diverse and may choose to have private weddings which might be just family and very close friends which can be as small as 25-30 people. Anyhow the point is mostly the decisions are theirs. Now usually an American girl dreams about her wedding day since she is a kid and usually the bride's dress is a BIG BIG deal. A decent bride's dress costs about 6000$ which is almost Rs.300,000. Not so small a wedding huh? The catering, band and the hall and jewellery and stay for your friends and family, and at last but my favourite - the wedding cake - we are probably looking at around a $60,000 wedding. Wait a second. That is about 30 lakhs INR. Wow..... Didn't we think that the western wedding very compact and mock our Indian wedding as a BIG FAT INDIAN WEDDING a while ago? Oh My God. Yes. OK. At least I did. 

Dont feel guilty. Now this is my favourite part. The five point analysis on Indian and American Wedding. 

Point 1 : Well Thought About ?

Western wedding revolves mostly around the bride and groom and parents are mostly not involved. Indian wedding on the other hand, revolves around parents or friends, and hence more heads involved. Point Indian Marriage. 

Point 2 : Stress on people 

Western wedding does put a lot of pressure on bride and groom. However it doesn't stress out the other people involved as much as the Indian wedding does. Point Western Wedding. 

Point 3 : Effect on two families involved

The western marriage doesn't bring in a lot of adjacency to the families involved. However at least at a formal level, the Indian wedding does. point Indian wedding. 

Point 4 : Pressure on the couple

The divorce is still a taboo in India compared to the western culture. Hence the Indian couples are under a lot of pressure compared to the westerners to make this work. Hence point Western Marriage. 

Now for the deciding factor. Point 5 : Effective Closeness of People or the Love Factor 

The fact that went in favour of the western marriage in the last point, actually kinda acted against it this time around. Its not that the western marriage is devoid of love. However, in a Indian marriage, since the couple have to make it work, usually the love factor is way more than the western marriage. Especially the factor that privacy is appreciated by the husband and wife, is a barrier in the effective closeness of the couple or it works against the love factor. 

Hence, when I look at it, on an average, the Indian Marriage still is better than the Western marriage. Now when I say this, don't get me wrong, there are still a lot of western culture which upholds the tradition of seven day marriages. Now its not only the economic growth, the master minds whom we produce or the scientific and military advances that India has made over the last few decades, its also the culture and tradition and the love that has made her stand where she is today. 

I am proud to be an Indian. I will join hands with my friends to make this a better place and uphold her culture and tradition. 

/mareechan

Monday, June 22, 2009

Commitment for Life - Part 1; Love v/s Arranged Marraige


My room mate has declared that he is going to get married soon. Very good news indeed. Now this transformation has just triggered a thought in my mind. Here is the deal..

He was just nice guy, staying in the other room and helped once in a while when I was in trouble and is very professional when it comes to work. While I am enjoying my bachelorhood and being single, suddenly after this declaration, my friend has undergone a major change. Wow....wow...wow. Wait a second. Just because he is going to marry someone, he has already started changing. He is now more accurate. He now does more things to make sure that I and other guys staying with us are not offended, and at last and by no means least.. Spends an awful lot of time on the phone. Anyhow this bizzare reactions made me think about my marraige. A real toughie.

Here is how it goes. I like my space. Whereever I am. For example this morning I was in the coffee shop near my office. Me and my office collegues hang out there because its a deserted place. We get a table and no body bothers us too much there. I choose that over my office cafeteria because office cafeteria is crowded. We might end up drinking our coffee standing. I am not so comfortable being so close to anybody for a very long time. Physically and Mentally. Initially I thought it was just me. But a few days ago, I saw a girl writing the same thing on her blog about her boy friend being so close to her and more often she feels frustrated and irritated. So its not just me. A lot of people feel the same way.

So what does this mean to you guys? I am not sure if you would have thought about it. Marraige is as big as any commitment can get. The holding hands, sharing thoughts and - what the hell I ll say it - sleeping together is fun. But wont you get a little edgy over things once the shine is off the apple? Now may be I am too young and thats why I am feeling this way. Now thats the whole point. May be if I am older I wouldnt feel the same way. Now I want to present two points here. One is love v/s arranged marraige and the second is western and Indian tradition of marraige.

Love v/s Arranged Marraige :-

Now love marraige only makes as much sense as arranged marraige. Both of these involves the same process but it is done by different induiduals. Love - if the boy and girl decides and Arranged - if the parents decide.

Point 1 : Anyway both has its own disadvantages and advantages. Both methods depend heavily on the deciding person. Now in this fashion, I am actually more inclined to arranged marraige because, hypothetically 4 people will be involved against 2 in love. Now there are exceptions both ways. - Arranged Marraige Wins

Point 2 : However sometimes money, social status and stuff like that causes problems more in arranged marraige than in love. Now you might argue, if a girl or a guy doesnt have any of the qualities, wont it be a problem in love marraige as well. Well the answer is if anything is a problem, most often they come up before or during the relationship and will be dealt with. - Love Marraige Wins

Point 3 : Arranged marraige as the name suggests, arranges the process and most often unites the two families, the bride's to the groom's. On the other hand, love marraige is not as efficient in doing this. More often than not, it might cause a rift between the families and even cause rivalry between parents and son/daughter. Arranged Marraige Wins

Point 4 : Arranged marraige often lacks the creativity to mark the beginning of a new era in two people's life. We are amused by the big fat indian wedding. But as I have once expressed before, it is staged. It can only induce a little bit of closeness to the two induiduals and it is a responsibility for them to bring up the bond. On the other hand, love marraige presents two induiduals who are mentally prepared for what they are about to do. - Love Marraige Wins

Point 5 : The future of the relationship for a man and his wife, is completely dependant on two induiduals, regardless of the way they were married. It simply doesnt matter. If both of them have enough patience, the right attitude and emotional quotient and a lot of other stuff, they could make it work. - No Point for Arranged or Love Marraige

Score : Its a tie. There are a zillion points that one could add here, I just added the ones that came to me off the top off my head. I think on an average, it will be a tie.

I think before I talk about the second point, western v/s Indian, I have to tell you what is a western style marraige in my view. I think this post is getting a bit too long for that topic to be discussed right away, so why dont we put it off for a couple of days... Till then, take care and be good.

/mareechan